Ascent Petrochem Holdings Co., Limited
Articles
Articles

Articles

Phthalic Anhydride Replacement by DCPD Derived Nadic Structures in Fiberglass Laminates

The substitution of phthalic anhydride by DCPD-derived nadic structures in unsaturated polyester resins for fiberglass laminates alters the steric environment of the ester condensation site, the concentration of copolymerizable unsaturation, and the solubility of the uncured resin in styrene. Orthophthalic anhydride functions as a low-cost saturated dibasic acid that terminates polycondensation, reduces fumarate unsaturation density, and raises molecular weight between crosslinks when compared with maleic anhydride alone. In contrast, the nadic structure obtained from the Diels-Alder reaction of cyclopentadiene and maleic anhydride inserts a bicyclic aliphatic segment with a pendant norbornene double bond and two carboxylic acid groups into the growing polyester. The resulting DCPD maleate backbone contains hydrophobic alicyclic rings that lower ester group concentration per unit mass, increase glass transition temperature, and reduce the styrene required for laminating viscosity. Typical orthophthalic laminating resins are diluted to 38–42 wt% styrene and exhibit heat distortion temperatures between 70 °C and 80 °C under ISO 75-2:2013 method A at 1.8 MPa. DCPD-nadic laminating resins with 28–34 wt% styrene produce cured castings with heat distortion temperatures in the 100–120 °C range when the same test method is applied. The change in backbone geometry also lowers volumetric shrinkage during cure, which has direct consequences for laminate thickness control, secondary bonding, and die-wall friction in continuous processing. The replacement is therefore not a neutral monomer substitution but a simultaneous change in rheology, reactivity, hygrothermal response, and compliance with volatile organic compound limits.

Could the Endo-to-Exo Ratio of the Nadic Anhydride Monomer Influence Ambient Cure Exotherm Enough to Compromise Laminate Through-Cure?

The Diels-Alder condensation between cyclopentadiene and maleic anhydride initially yields the endo isomer, which is the kinetic product. Esterification at 190–210 °C can drive partial conversion to the exo isomer; the exo isomer exposes the carboxyl groups for more complete chain extension and produces a resin with a higher acid number and more ordered packing. The endo-to-exo ratio in the final resin is not routinely controlled in many orthophthalic replacement operations, yet it affects the response to methyl ethyl ketone peroxide and cobalt octoate. Gel time measured according to ASTM D2471-99 at 25 °C using 1.5 phr MEKP with 9% active oxygen and 0.3 phr cobalt octoate at 6% Co typically falls between 18 min and 28 min for DCPD-nadic laminating resins, compared with 12–18 min for orthophthalic controls at the same initiator loading. Peak exotherm recorded in a 100 g water bath at 25 °C is generally 140–170 °C for the DCPD-nadic system and 180–220 °C for the orthophthalic system. The reduced exotherm is partially due to lower styrene content and partially due to the lower reactivity of the norbornene double bond in the DCPD backbone. This can produce a wider processing window for thick laminates but may leave under-cure in corners or behind gelcoat details if the ambient temperature drops below 15 °C. In open-mould construction, the peak exotherm must remain above 120 °C for a minimum of 10 min to achieve full crosslinking through a 6 mm laminate. The endo isomer also introduces steric hindrance at the polyester backbone, which slows the final conversion of maleate to fumarate during cook and can shift the onset of cure by several minutes. Producers changing from orthophthalic resin should therefore specify the isomer ratio or request a gel time curve from the resin supplier, because the same peroxide loading and reinforcement schedule will not reproduce the same interval from catalysation to Barcol hardness development.

Across open-mould marine lamination with 450 g/m² emulsion-bound E-glass chopped strand mat, the replacement of a 38 wt% styrene orthophthalic resin by a 31 wt% styrene DCPD-nadic maleate resin alters wet-out, roll-out effort, and secondary bonding. Mixed viscosity at 23 °C measured with a Brookfield RVT spindle 3 at 60 rpm is typically 200–280 mPa·s for the low-styrene DCPD-nadic laminating resin, whereas the orthophthalic resin displays 350–450 mPa·s. The lower viscosity promotes rapid wet-out of 450 g/m² mat but also increases the risk of resin-rich puddles at hull stringer intersections if the operator maintains the same rolling pattern. In production-scale open moulding, the DCPD-nadic resin reaches Barcol hardness 40–45 after 24 h at 23 °C, compared with 45–50 for the orthophthalic control, and full cure is confirmed by a Barcol hardness increase of less than 4 units between 24 h and 72 h. Secondary bonding of a subsequent laminate layer requires either an air-drying resin formulation without paraffin wax or surface abrasion to 80–120 grit after the first layer has cured beyond the tacky state. The absence of residual surface tack in DCPD-nadic systems, caused by lower volatile loss and a different air-inhibition response, can reduce intercoat adhesion if lamination is delayed beyond 12 h; bonding is therefore performed within 6 h or after mechanical abrasion. Pre-drying of glass is required at relative humidity above 60% because adsorbed moisture competes with the cobalt promoter and retards the decomposition of methyl ethyl ketone peroxide. The lower styrene content also reduces air emissions during open-mould wet-out, but the change is not sufficient to eliminate the need for vapour suppressants in districts with stringent local rules. Operators must be retrained to use lighter rolling pressure because the low-viscosity DCPD-nadic resin can move across the laminate face more quickly than the orthophthalic control and wash out gelcoat edges if the gelcoat is not fully cured.

Hydrolytic Robustness of the DCPD-Nadic Backbone in Dilute Sulphuric Acid Service

Immersion testing according to ISO 175:2010 in 25% sulphuric acid at 40 °C for 28 days shows that orthophthalic laminates often retain 60–70% of initial flexural strength when tested by ISO 14125:1998, while DCPD-nadic laminates retain 80–90%. The difference arises because the nadic alicyclic segment reduces the number of aromatic ester linkages that are susceptible to acid-catalysed hydrolysis and lowers water absorption measured by ISO 62:2008 to 0.2–0.4% after 28 days at 23 °C, compared with 0.5–0.8% for orthophthalic laminates. The cured network contains fumarate crosslinks, unreacted norbornene double bonds, and styrene bridges; the hydrophobic bicyclic ring restricts diffusion of hydrated protons to the ester carbonyl. However, the improvement is conditional on complete post-cure. Laminates cured only at ambient temperature and not post-cured show a smaller separation because residual styrene and unpolymerised fumarate sites act as diffusion channels. For chemical service, a post-cure of 4 h at 80 °C or 2 h at 100 °C is required to approach the published retention data. The addition of 10–15 phr of a silane coupling agent to the resin is permissible if the silane is vinyl-functional; amino-functional silanes should be avoided due to premature peroxide decomposition and surface dulling. In storage tank linings and secondary containment barriers, the use of a DCPD-nadic resin alone does not replace the need for a surfacing veil. The corrosion barrier should still contain a 0.3 mm chemical-resistant veil with 90% resin by volume, because glass fibres are attacked by acidic media and create wicking paths through the laminate. The selection of DCPD-nadic chemistry for mineral-acid service should be confirmed by immersion testing in the specific concentration and temperature envelope, because published data for this specific configuration is limited for concentrations above 50% and for oxidising acids such as nitric acid.

Sheet moulding compound lines operating at carrier speeds of 25–40 m/min require the paste to mature from an initial viscosity of 15,000–25,000 mPa·s to 40,000,000–60,000,000 mPa·s within 24–48 h at 32 °C before the sheet is compression moulded at 150 °C and 80–100 bar. Orthophthalic SMC resins typically carry acid numbers of 20–30 mg KOH/g and require 1.0–1.5 phr magnesium oxide for thickening; DCPD-nadic resins frequently have acid numbers between 5 mg KOH/g and 15 mg KOH/g, which lowers the MgO demand to 0.4–0.8 phr. The lower acid number also slows the initial thickening rate and can produce a softer sheet at 24 h if the same MgO loading is used without reformulation. Production lines must set the maturation room at 28–32 °C and 40–50% relative humidity; pre-drying of filler and paste is required above 60% relative humidity because water accelerates MgO hydrate formation and produces premature viscosity spikes. Moulding trials show that a DCPD-nadic SMC with 25 wt% glass, 150 phr calcium carbonate, and 0.6 phr MgO reaches moulding viscosity after 48 h and cures to a Barcol hardness of 50–55 in a 3 min cycle. The replacement is not drop-in because the lower initial acid number alters the maturation curve and the in-mould flow path; flow distance in a 200 mm spiral flow tool can decrease by 10–15% if the paste is moulded at the same viscosity but with a more rigid backbone. Compression moulding in matched metal dies at 150 °C requires vacuum-assisted venting to prevent porosity caused by lower styrene content, which reduces the amount of volatile monomer available to flush trapped air from the cavity. Fillers and low-profile additives must be re-optimised because the DCPD-nadic backbone shrinks less than the orthophthalic backbone and may not generate the same microvoiding pattern in the cured part. The absence of a phthalic aromatic ring also changes the solubility parameter of the matrix and affects pigment wetting, especially with carbon black and phthalocyanine blue.

If Vacuum Infusion Retains the Same Fibre Stack and Inlet Porting, Resin Viscosity Rather Than Reactivity Becomes the Primary Process Constraint

In vacuum infusion of 600 g/m² quadraxial E-glass with a 10 mm balsa or PVC core, the resin must remain below 300 mPa·s during the 30–45 min injection window and must not gel before the outlet side is filled. An orthophthalic resin at 38 wt% styrene often enters the laminate at 350–450 mPa·s at 23 °C, which requires careful porting at 0.8–1.0 m intervals and can produce dry spots in thick sections. A DCPD-nadic resin at 30 wt% styrene with a mixed viscosity of 180–250 mPa·s wets the same stack more readily, but its longer gel time of 40–60 min with 1.5 phr MEKP and 0.2 phr cobalt 6% means the resin remains mobile long enough for gravity-driven channelling to occur in cored sections with open cells or scored grooves. The processing window is therefore bounded by the onset of viscosity build at 30–40 min and the minimum permeability of the fibre stack. If the vacuum level is 5–10 mbar absolute and the resin inlet temperature is 20–23 °C, the DCPD-nadic resin can achieve complete fill of a 2 m by 1 m laminate in 15–20 min; the same orthophthalic resin may require 25–35 min. Post-fill compaction is improved by the lower shrinkage of the DCPD-nadic matrix, which reduces the final laminate thickness variation to ±0.2 mm across a 4 mm target section, compared with ±0.4 mm for the orthophthalic control. This does not remove the need for a high-flow distribution medium; rather, it moves the constraint from resin wet-out to degassing and fill-path control. If the infusion is conducted at resin inlet temperatures above 30 °C, the gel time of the DCPD-nadic system shortens to 20–25 min and can cause premature resin trapping in thick core transitions. When the same stack is used for both resins, the lower viscosity of the DCPD-nadic formulation can create local resin-rich areas around the vacuum outlet if the outlet is not relocated from the last fill point to a peripheral overflow channel. Published data for this specific configuration is limited for laminates thicker than 15 mm, so full-thickness flow trials are required before production release.

PropertyTest methodOrthophthalic laminateDCPD-nadic laminate
Tensile strengthISO 527-4:202180–90 MPa95–105 MPa
Flexural strengthISO 14125:1998180–220 MPa220–270 MPa
Flexural modulusISO 14125:19987.0–8.0 GPa7.5–9.0 GPa
Heat distortion temperatureISO 75-2:2013 method A70–80 °C100–120 °C
Water absorption after 28 days at 23 °CISO 62:20080.5–0.8%0.2–0.4%
Barcol hardnessASTM D2583-13a45–5050–55

The values in the table represent typical supplier technical bulletin ranges for laminates containing 30 wt% E-glass chopped strand mat and post-cured for 4 h at 80 °C; values will shift with glass orientation, resin formulation, catalyst level, and laminate void content.

Flame performance in laminated structures for transportation interiors is influenced by the aromatic content of the polyester backbone and the filler loading rather than by the anhydride replacement alone. In transportation interior laminates, smoke density measured by ISO 5659-2 or ASTM E662 depends more strongly on aluminium trihydrate loading than on the choice between orthophthalic and DCPD-nadic backbone chemistry. Orthophthalic anhydride contributes aromatic rings that can increase char formation under non-flaming radiant heat; DCPD-nadic alicyclic segments reduce the intrinsic aromatic carbon fraction and may lower specific optical density once styrene and filler combustion are normalised, but published data for this specific configuration is limited. A laminate without fire-retardant filler will fail ASTM E84 Class I flame spread limits regardless of the anhydride source. Production laminates requiring 35–40 phr of aluminium trihydrate in a DCPD-nadic resin can achieve ISO 5659-2 maximum specific optical density values below 300 at 50 kW/m² when tested at 25 mm specimen thickness, but this depends on glass content and surfacing veil. The use of antimony oxide with a halogenated flame retardant in a DCPD-nadic matrix is operationally limited by viscosity build and dispersion difficulty in high-speed impingement mixers; the same formulation in an orthophthalic matrix also requires high-shear mixing but has a wider viscosity tolerance. No claim of inherent fire performance should be made for DCPD-nadic non-halogenated systems without a full ISO 5660-1 cone calorimeter test at the intended thickness and glass lay-up. Halogenated additives combined with amine-based synergists should be avoided because the amine can deactivate the cobalt promoter and produce inconsistent gelation. Surface veils in fire-rated laminates must be acid-resistant if the part is exposed to repeated condensation, because the veil itself can delaminate before the structural laminate fails.

Continuous Pultrusion Thermal Profiling and Pull Force with DCPD-Nadic Maleate Matrices

Pultrusion of 50–60 wt% glass rovings in a DCPD-nadic resin requires a die temperature profile that compensates for the delayed gel point and the higher heat distortion temperature after cure. A three-zone heated die of 1.2 m length is typically set at 90 °C in the entrance zone, 130 °C in the gelation zone, and 160 °C in the final cure zone; the line speed is maintained between 0.8 m/min and 1.5 m/min. The lower peak exotherm of the DCPD-nadic system prevents premature blistering at the die wall but also requires that the die exit temperature remain above 150 °C for at least 15 s residence time to reach full cure. Pull force measured on a 30 kN load cell is typically 15–25 kN for a 100 mm by 6 mm flat profile, compared with 18–30 kN for an orthophthalic resin with the same glass volume. The difference arises from lower volumetric shrinkage of the DCPD-nadic matrix, which reduces die wall friction. Surface cracking and fibre breakout increase if the first die zone exceeds 100 °C because the resin gels before full compaction; the absence of a phthalic aromatic segment lowers resin toughness and can increase edge chipping in profiles with sharp corners. A filler loading of 10–15 phr of calcium carbonate or alumina trihydrate is used to maintain surface hardness and reduce fibre print. Post-cure is not required for structural pultrusions if the die exit cure is verified by ASTM D2583-13a Barcol hardness above 50 and by a residual styrene content below 0.1 wt% measured by gas chromatography after extraction. Tensile strength of 12 mm pultruded rod tested by ASTM D3916-16 typically increases by 10–20 MPa when the matrix is changed from orthophthalic to DCPD-nadic at equal glass content, but elongation at break decreases by 0.2–0.5 percentage points, so the change is unsuitable for energy-absorbing profiles without redesign. The combination of DCPD-nadic resin with amine-based mould release agents should be avoided because the amine can decompose the peroxide initiator and create intermittent gel spots on the pultruded surface. If the resin bath is heated to reduce viscosity, the bath temperature must not exceed 30 °C because the DCPD-nadic formulation with cobalt promoter and low styrene content will exhibit a pot life shorter than 20 min in the open bath.

What Processing Window Exists for Hot-Wet Property Retention after Anhydride Replacement?

Hot-wet property retention is evaluated by immersion in 80 °C demineralised water for 1000 h followed by ISO 14125:1998 flexural testing at 23 °C. Orthophthalic laminates typically retain 55–65% of dry flexural strength under these conditions, while DCPD-nadic laminates retain 75–85% when the laminate has been post-cured at 80 °C for 4 h. Dynamic mechanical analysis of the cured network shows a dry glass transition temperature near 115–125 °C for the DCPD-nadic system and 80–90 °C for the orthophthalic control; after hot-wet conditioning, the DCPD-nadic glass transition temperature may fall by 10–15 °C, while the orthophthalic system can fall by 25–35 °C. The smaller depression is due to lower equilibrium water uptake and reduced plasticisation of the ester linkages. The operational boundary is set by the combination of temperature and hydrolysis time: DCPD-nadic laminates should not be exposed to pressurised water above 100 °C without a styrene-free corrosion liner, because the unreacted norbornene double bonds can undergo oxidative degradation and the glass fibre sizing degrades more rapidly than the resin matrix. The replacement of phthalic anhydride by DCPD-derived nadic structures improves hot-wet flexural strength retention only when the resin synthesis has converted the majority of maleate unsaturation to fumarate; resin batches with incomplete isomerisation show a lower retention and a wider scatter in ISO 14125:1998 results. Laminators must specify acid number, residual maleate content by infrared spectroscopy, and a hot-wet retention certificate for each batch when the part is destined for continuous service in humid conditions above 60 °C. Published data for this specific configuration is limited for immersion beyond 5000 h, so outdoor accelerated weathering programmes should be conducted before replacing orthophthalic gelcoat and laminating systems in structural water-contact applications.

Regulatory pressure on styrene emissions from open moulding shifts the replacement calculation beyond mechanical properties and into permitted monomer content per kilogram of resin. Many orthophthalic laminating resins are supplied at 38–42 wt% styrene, while DCPD-nadic laminating resins are formulated at 28–34 wt% styrene and can be further modified with 2–5 wt% of a wax-free vapour suppressant to meet local air quality requirements. The reduction in monomer content changes the mass balance for compliance with EU Directive 2004/42/EC or US EPA NESHAP 40 CFR Part 63 subpart WWWW only when the resin is applied without increasing the total resin uptake per laminate. Production shops that switch to a low-styrene DCPD-nadic resin but do not recalibrate wet-out ratios may apply 10–15% more resin by mass, erasing the emission benefit. Operator exposure monitoring for styrene in the breathing zone should follow the relevant national standard such as NIOSH 2501 for thermal desorption sampling; the lower monomer content of DCPD-nadic laminating resin reduces the measured air concentration but does not eliminate the need for ventilation. The formulation shift also affects waste resin classification under local hazardous waste rules because the reduced solvent content can lower the flash point of the mixed resin only slightly, while the peroxide promoter in the mixed state remains a reactive hazard. No forward-looking conclusion is drawn; the replacement is acceptable only when the resin supplier provides a complete reactivity curve, the fabricator verifies wet-out and cure in the actual laminate schedule, and the end-user confirms chemical or hygrothermal compatibility with the intended service environment.

Related Articles